Have you ever been the victim of a bait & switch? When I was in college, I was hired at a restaurant to run the open-fire grill where I would be cooking steaks, chops & chicken. I was excited because that’s just fun. But in my first day, they told me the dishwasher had quit the day before and that they “just needed me to cover for 1-2 days,” and when those 1-2 days passed…I was still on dish and only scheduled for dish for the foreseeable future…they never intended me to run the grill. But they knew no one wanted to come in to work as their dishwasher.
Needless to say, I wasn’t there long, and giving my notice wasn’t heartbreaking.
When we promote our ministries, we show community opportunities, and we invite people to be part of the life of the church, I don’t know that we’re entirely honest about that process.
And don’t get me wrong. I love good planning & strategy. I like a clear pathway for discipleship & involvement. But in a lot of the non-mainline, Protestant spaces we’re very open about where we’d love to see people grow – but we oversell how “quick & easy” that process is.
What we present is often:
Come to our “Explore/Get to Know Us” class, join a Bible study group, get plugged into a ministry and start serving the community…and boom!…you’re in!
There’s a lot of stuff that’s geared toward the already-in-the-know, self-starting extrovert, but not so much for the quiet people, those new to the faith & folks who aren’t ready to habla our church Español. They can’t sprechen sie our Deutsch & self-starting isn’t their norm.
And we know, if we’re being honest, that connecting to community is something that comes over time. Friendships and those arms-around-each-other, laughing high-five pictures we have on our website? That’s not something we see normally the week after someone commits to partnership with the church or right after their life is surrendered to Christ.
Connection usually takes time.
So, what are we inviting people to? What are we showing them? What unspoken promises are we making? — And ultimately, what are we truly, honestly going to help them do in contrast to where does our discipleship process hit its own functional boundaries?
If someone needs a ride, so they can be consistent & get connected, will we help them set that up?
If they need benevolence help on day 1 or require assistance to locate and visit a food bank, will we go with them? If they’re a single parent and they need someone to pick their kid up from school a few times during the week…will we take that step with them?
There are barriers to belonging.
Will we serve people as Jesus would in order to truly take them into the community of Christ?
Will we go beyond the scope of our 101, 201, 301 classes in order to treat them like family…or do we say “Sorry, that’s not something we do.”
Those happy-family pictures on the website?
The impressions of “this is who we are…” that we love promoting?
Are those real?
Or is it just marketing?
Is it our life, heart & practice?
Or does showing that just make us feel better about a mask we wear?
What are we inviting people to?
And is that an honest invitation?
For the individual:
- Ask yourself how you would respond if asked to help connect someone like this. What are you prepared to do, & are you trusting God to grow you in what’s hard?
For church leaders & staff:
- Take a good, hard look at what you’re advertising, think about the “relative ease” of actually walking that out, and ask someone who is outside of your circle to evaluate your process honestly.
- Consider a linked article in your “About Us” or “I’m New” or “Membership” sections of your site that addresses the reality of connection, the pathway you all offer and where you’re ready to give help. Be honest & anticipate needs.